Who Had the Real Intel on the War

This is the second of two pieces dedicated to shame and honor in the Bush era. The first was “The Wall of Shame.”

On Nov. 2, 2005, I found myself in a familiar situation – at a protest. This time, it was the New York version of the World Can’t Wait nationwide protest on the first anniversary of George W. Bush’s reelection. In some ways the scene was typical. Heavy police presence for the rally. Lots of police vans. The ubiquitous metal barricades. And that vestigial gift of the August 2004 Republican National Convention in the Big Apple: the NYPD scooter brigade – complete with flexi-cuffs informally used to weaponize the scooters by lashing billy clubs to them.

The police had been called out in force because the kids were out in force. While I saw many of the usual suspects (including my rapidly aging self), the day belonged to throngs of high-school and college kids – some of whom walked out of class, braving suspensions. Many were too young to vote or buy alcohol, though not to enlist in the military. (Go figure.) It was a fired-up, diverse crowd that grooved to the excellent musicianship and furious lyrics of the genre-bending Brooklyn quintet, Outernational, and gave it up for speakers ranging from fiery city councilwoman Margarita Lopez to former diplomat Ann Wright, who called on the crowd to spend Thanksgiving with her and other hearty activist souls at Camp Casey in Crawford, Texas.

Then they took to the streets. Carrying a creative mélange of signs, clad in “Resist Or Die!” T-shirts, and wearing green stickers bearing the words of their signature chant – “Drive out the Bush regime, the world can’t wait!” – they commenced a two-mile march through Manhattan to Times Square. They yelled or sang familiar call-and-response chants. “Whose streets? Our streets!” “What do we want? Peace! When do we want it? Now!” They implored passersby to join the march – and I even saw an elderly man do so. Many drivers in cars smiled or honked horns in support, while office workers in windows above flashed peace signs, cheered, or gave thumbs-up. Then there was the fellow, high above in dress shirt and tie, who held his own homemade sign to a window: “Get a job.” He was met by the expected opprobrium and a chant just for him: “Get a clue! Get a clue!”

Finally, he mouthed back – at least it looked that way to me – “You get a clue!” And I was reminded of something that is almost never mentioned anymore. I remember well the huge rallies and marches in New York, Washington, and elsewhere as the Bush administration rushed headlong into war, claiming the need to find weapons of mass destruction that were never there and strangle a threat that never existed. It should make you think about who had a clue, and who needed to get one.

In a recent column in the New York Times, Maureen Dowd called attention to a striking Los Angeles Times op-ed by retired Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson, Colin Powell’s former chief of staff. He wrote that American “foreign policy had been hijacked by ‘a secretive, little-known cabal’ [headed by Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld] that hated dissent.” At the end of her piece, Dowd suggested that President Bush ought to take back the Medal of Freedom he gave to former CIA chief George Tenet and instead award one to Wilkerson.

As striking as Wilkerson’s revelations were, the more striking thing may be that those of us out protesting in the streets before the first shock-and-awe missiles landed on Baghdad didn’t need such information (much as we would then have wished for a voice like his to speak out). We didn’t need the latest intel from generals or politicians or spymasters with top-secret access to reports from the intelligence community. We did better without it. On Feb. 15, 2003, at least 10 million people in 400 cities in 60 countries, across 5 continents, saw what was about to happen plenty clearly. They saw that the coming war would be illegitimate, deadly, and destructive. They sensed that invading Iraq would, in the long run, be no cakewalk. They already understood that what the Bush administration so clearly planned to do was based on lies. And they knew it was all wrong – not from the start, or months or years later – but before it ever began.

If medals are being given out, perhaps this is what should never be forgotten. It was the “crazies” in the streets. It was kids in weird clothes with strange hair. It was a man holding a puppet and a woman with a homemade sign. They knew then what it took the majority of Americans years to figure out: that the war would be a disaster and that, in any case, it was wrong. Those people, braving a bitterly cold day in New York City in February 2003, had better intel, more foresight, and better judgment than the military, the intelligence agencies, and especially the president and vice president of the United States and all their advisers.

I can’t get that man with his little sign high in the window out of my head or the thought that facts like these are so easily forgotten. What I might tell him, were he to decide to come down and ask what I thought, is this: Remember well that if you want the real story, if you want the unvarnished truth, if you want the intel that trillions can’t buy, you just might find it in the streets. It might be the only place left where you can actually get a clue.

Nick Turse works in the Department of Epidemiology at Columbia University and is the associate editor and research director of TomDispatch.com. He has written for the Los Angeles Times, the San Francisco Chronicle, the Village Voice, and regularly for TomDispatch on the military-corporate complex, the homeland security state, and various other topics.

Copyright 2005 Nick Turse

Author: Tom Engelhardt

An editor in publishing for the last 25 years, Tom Engelhardt is the author of The End of Victory Culture, a history of American triumphalism in the Cold War era, now out in a revised edition with a new preface and afterword, and Mission Unaccomplished, TomDispatch Interviews With American Iconoclasts and Dissenters. He is at present consulting editor for Metropolitan Books, a fellow of the Nation Institute, and a teaching fellow at the journalism school of the University of California, Berkeley. Visit his Web site. This article originally appeared at TomDispatch.com. To stay on top of important articles like these, sign up to receive the latest updates from TomDispatch.com.