US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World
Americans have lost their ability for introspection, thereby revealing their astounding hypocrisy to the world.
U.S. War Secretary Robert Gates has condemned the Associated Press and a reporter, Julie Jacobson, embedded with U.S. troops in Afghanistan, for taking and releasing a photo of a U.S. Marine who was wounded in action and died from his injury.
The photographer was on patrol with the Marines when they came under fire. She found the courage and presence of mind to do her job. Her reward is to be condemned by the warmonger Gates as "insensitive." Gates says her employer, the Associated Press, lacks "judgment and common decency."
The American Legion jumped in and denounced the Associated Press for a "stunning lack of compassion and common decency."
To stem opposition to its wars, the War Department hides signs of American casualties from the public. Angry that evidence escaped the censor, the war secretary and the American Legion attacked with politically correct jargon: "insensitive," "offended," and the "anguish" and "pain and suffering" inflicted upon the Marine’s family. The War Department sounds like it is preparing a harassment tort.
Isn’t this passing the buck? The Marine lost his life not because of the Associated Press and a photographer, but because of the war criminals – Gates, Bush, Cheney, Obama, and the U.S. Congress that supports wars of naked aggression that serve no American purpose, but which keep campaign coffers filled with contributions from the armaments companies.
Marine Lance Cpl. Joshua M. Bernard is dead because the U.S. government and a significant percentage of the U.S. population believe that the U.S. has the right to invade, bomb, and occupy other peoples who have raised no hand against us but are demonized with lies and propaganda.
For the American war secretary it is a photo that is insensitive, not America’s assertion of the right to determine the fate of Afghanistan with bombs and soldiers.
The exceptional "virtuous nation" does not think it is insensitive for America’s bombs to blow innocent villagers to pieces. On Sept. 4, the day before Gates’ outburst over the "insensitive" photo, Agence France Presse reported from Afghanistan that a U.S./NATO air strike had killed large numbers of villagers who had come to get fuel from two tankers that had been hijacked from negligent and inattentive occupation forces:
"’Nobody was in one piece. Hands, legs, and body parts were scattered everywhere. Those who were away from the fuel tanker were badly burnt,’ said 32-year-old Mohammad Daud, depicting a scene from hell. The burned-out shells of the tankers, still smoking in marooned wrecks on the riverbank, were surrounded by the charred-meat remains of villagers from Chahar Dara district in Kunduz province, near the Tajik border. Dr. Farid Rahid, a spokesperson in Kabul for the ministry of health, said up to 250 villagers had been near the tankers when the air strike was called in."
What does the world think of the United States? The American war secretary and a U.S. military veterans association think a photo of an injured and dying American soldier is insensitive, but not the wipeout of an Afghan village that came to get needed fuel.
The U.S. government is like a criminal who accuses the police of his crime when he is arrested or a sociopathic abuser who blames the victim. It is a known fact that the CIA has violated U.S. law and international law with its assassinations, kidnappings, and torture. But it is not this criminal agency that will be held accountable. Instead, those who will be punished will be those moral beings who, appalled at the illegality and inhumanity of the CIA, leaked the evidence of the agency’s crimes. The CIA has asked the U.S. Justice (sic) Department to investigate what the CIA alleges is the "criminal disclosure" of its secret program to murder suspected foreign terrorist leaders abroad. As we learned from Gitmo, those suspected by America are overwhelmingly innocent.
The CIA program is so indefensible that when CIA director Leon Panetta found out about it six months after being in office, he cancelled the program (assuming those running the program obeyed) and informed Congress.
Yet, the CIA wants the person who revealed its crime to be punished for revealing secret information. A secret agency this unmoored from moral and legal standards is a greater threat to our country than are terrorists. Who knows what false flag operation it will pull off in order to provide justification and support for its agenda. An agency that is more liability than benefit should be abolished.
The agency’s program of assassinating terrorist leaders is itself fraught with contradictions and dangers. The hatred created by the U.S. and Israel is independent of any leader. If one is killed, others take his place. The most likely outcome of the CIA assassination program is that the agency will be manipulated by rivals, just as the FBI was used by one mafia family to eliminate another. In order to establish credibility with groups that they are attempting to penetrate, CIA agents will be drawn into participating in violent acts against the U.S. and its allies.
Accusing the truthteller instead of the evildoer is the position that the neoconservatives took against the New York Times when after one year’s delay, which gave George W. Bush time to get reelected, the Times published the NSA leak that revealed that the Bush administration was committing felonies by violating the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The neocons, especially those associated with Commentary magazine, wanted the New York Times indicted for treason. To the evil neocon mind, anything that interferes with their diabolical agenda is treason.
This is the way many Americans think. America über alles! No one counts but us (and Israel). The deaths we inflict and the pain and suffering we bring to others are merely collateral damage on the bloody path to American hegemony.
The attitude of the "freedom and democracy" U.S. government is that anyone who complains of illegality or immorality or inhumanity is a traitor. The Republican Sen. Christopher S. Bond is a recent example. Bond got on his high horse about "irreparable damage" to the CIA from the disclosures of its criminal activities. Bond wants those "back stabbers" who revealed the CIA’s wrongdoings to be held accountable. Bond is unable to grasp that it is the criminal activities, not their disclosure, that is the source of the problem. Obviously, the Whistleblower Protection Act has no support from Sen. Bond, who sees it as just another law to plough under.
This is where the U.S. government stands today: Ignoring and covering up government crimes is the patriotic thing to do. To reveal the government’s crimes is an act of treason. Many Americans on both sides of the aisle agree.
Yet, they still think that they are The Virtuous Nation, the exceptional nation, the salt of the earth.
Read more by Paul Craig Roberts
- Have Americans Traded Freedom For Security? – December 25th, 2009
- Myths of Our Time – November 12th, 2009
- America, Israel’s Lackey – November 11th, 2009
- The Evil Empire – November 6th, 2009
- The Nobel War Prize – October 9th, 2009





Vultwulf
September 7th, 2009 at 7:36 am
The crimes the article mentions are unlikely to be punished; but the hubris that led to them will be punished by at least a partial collapse of the US imperium. The US has debased not only its foreign policy but its currency and overextended its military. History has never been kind to countries that make such blunders.
Tweets that mention US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World by Paul Craig Roberts -- Antiwar.com -- Topsy.com
September 7th, 2009 at 12:37 am
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Rebecca York, unes latib and Liberty Ideals. Rebecca York said: RT @libertyideals: US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World #libertarian http://bit.ly/wV09h [...]
Valerianus
September 7th, 2009 at 12:23 pm
The Guardian published the following regarding the dead Marine's father:
"Three weeks before Joshua died, Bernard Snr had written to his congressman expressing frustration at what he said was a change in the rules of engagement to spare civilians, calling the move 'disgraceful, immoral and fatal' to American forces in combat."
I'd like to tell Bernard Senior that he is a nasty piece of work whose only just fate is to be napalmed by an invading army. By his sociopathic standards, the civilians killed in the 9-11 attacks count just the same as the Afghan villagers that he would so casually mow down for the sake of his dead kid.
U.S. Hypocrisy Astonishes The World – Marine Lance Cpl. J. Bernard « The Tonka Report
September 7th, 2009 at 10:49 am
[...] http://original.antiwar.com/roberts/2009/09/06/us-hypocrisy-astonishes/ Leave a Comment [...]
Henry_Clemens
September 7th, 2009 at 6:51 pm
Mr. Roberts – a real American patriot – tells the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. In its present form, America's central government is as bad, if not worse, than were the evil and satanic governments of either Hitler's Germany or Stalin's USSR. If America's founders were alive and could see what has happened to their beloved republic, they would be mortifed.
September 7, 2009 « Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes?
September 7th, 2009 at 12:35 pm
[...] http://original.antiwar.com/roberts/2009/09/06/us-hypocrisy-astonishes/ [...]
retiretheempire
September 7th, 2009 at 7:55 pm
It's real unfortunate how many in the public respond to this type of propaganda from Mr. Gates. It convinces me that Mr. Gates' little outburst was a choreographed charade meant only for domestic comsumption. And of course to intimidate the media. When bandwagon members of the public express indignation at the AP for doing their job by reporting what's actually happening in the war zones, we should express our own indignation at the government for the outrageous hypocrisy and perfidy they show by condemning those who expose the consequences of their crimes. Otherwise daring independent journalists will succumb to this type of pressure in a heartbeat and who could blame them.
US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World by Paul Craig Roberts — Antiwar.com « All In One Blog Information
September 7th, 2009 at 1:52 pm
[...] View original here: US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World by Paul Craig Roberts — Antiwar.com [...]
US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World by Paul Craig Roberts — Antiwar.com - Special Blog
September 7th, 2009 at 3:09 pm
[...] is the original: US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World by Paul Craig Roberts — Antiwar.com :afghan, around-here-, chief-executive, Home, injured-and, military-veterans, once-again, [...]
GrizzlyBear01
September 7th, 2009 at 11:21 pm
There seems little doubt that there are significant issues with the NATO (read US and various allies, including some of my fellow Aussies) intervention in Afghanistan. I certainly have great concerns with the way the war is being conducted. I also have great concerns at the attitudes of many US officials on matters relating to free speech – in other words, it is only free when you say what we want you to say.
However, if there is one war going on in the world that has some justification, it has to be the Afghan war. The consequences to the Afghan people of a NATO withdrawal are horrific – have we so soon forgotten the nature of the Taliban government last time around? In this case, it seems that it is not the war as such that should be criticised, but the clumsily, stupidly and savagely destructive manner in which it is being conducted.
Regards,
A mostly ant-war GrizzlyBear01
Henry_Clemens
September 8th, 2009 at 2:21 am
Sir, I must respectfully disagree. The country of Afghanistan did not attack the U.S. or Austrailia. The war against Afghanistan was, and is, an unjustifiable war of offense. Tens of thousands of innocent people have been slaughtered because the U.S. invaded Afghanistan. I am an American citizen who loves his country. But I will not defend my country's government when it is in the wrong because that would be immoral and just plain stupid.
bogi666
September 8th, 2009 at 11:21 am
It's an ominous sign when the truth is criminalized and the war criminals, Gates, Bush,Cheney Obushama etal start deciding who the war criminals are and they determine that a war criminal are those who tell the truth. As for the American Legion, well their is a reason its membership, as are all Veteran organization, is dwindling. Those in the Legion who complain should be sent to Afghanistan and age shouldn't be a barrier since just recently a 59 year old soldier was killed there.
US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World « when beeing ANTI means being FOR human rights, coexistence and peace
September 10th, 2009 at 1:14 am
[...] Ref: Antiwar.com [...]
Another War in the Works
September 29th, 2009 at 10:16 pm
[...] US Hypocrisy Astonishes the World – September 6th, 2009 [...]