If enthusiastic White House and Congressional support could solve Washington’s public diplomacy problems, Dina Habib Powell would be well on her way to becoming a national heroine.
The Egyptian-born Powell, currently the top personnel official at the White House, is about to be confirmed as Pres. George W. Bush’s choice to be assistant secretary of state for Educational and Cultural Affairs (ECA). She will supervise all international student and other cultural exchange programs and serve as senior deputy to Karen Hughes, the longtime Bush confidante who has been nominated to direct all U.S. public diplomacy efforts.
Powell, whose parents emigrated from Egypt when she was a child, speaks fluent Arabic. She has risen quickly through Republican Party ranks, serving in the personnel office of the Bush-Cheney transition team and as director of Congressional Affairs for the Republican National Committee.
At her confirmation hearing before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on May 26, New Hampshire Republican Senator John Sununu, himself an Arab-American, observed, "Ms. Powell was born in the Middle East but raised in the United States. Who better to understand many of the challenges that lie before us, particularly in engaging with the Muslim world?"
And Democratic Senator Russ Feingold of Wisconsin – a consistent critic of the Bush administration and the only senator to vote against the USA Patriot Act – applauded Powell’s dedication to dialogue and assured her, "you will have strong allies on both sides of the aisle."
Addressing the committee, Powell acknowledged the challenges facing U.S. public diplomacy efforts. She said, "Our nation must engage with the rest of the world. But to be successful, we must listen. Our interaction with the world must be a conversation, not a monologue."
She said she is committed to widening the "two-way highway of people-to-people exchange," adding that she would work to "ensure international students know they are welcome at U.S. colleges, encourage more women and girls to participate in exchange programs, and enlist the private sector more fully in our public diplomacy efforts."
Powell has also expressed her views during public diplomacy during trips abroad. In Egypt, she addressed the widely held perception that the U.S. is attempting to impose its ideas of democracy on others.
"We do not wish to impose reform. It is not our place," she said. "We want to listen to the voices of the region and where it is appropriate, lend a helping hand."
She said that the terrorist attacks of Sep.11, 2001 triggered a "psyche change for the American people". Despite that, she added, one day later, "the president visited a mosque, took off his shoes and paid his respects, and said ‘this should not [make people] even begin to think about discrimination against people of Arab descent’. Shortly thereafter, racial profiling was made a federal crime."
Powell was asked at the same visit to Egypt, sponsored by Al Ahram, one of Egypt’s most respected newspapers, about Christian fundamentalism and anti-Muslim prejudice in the Bush administration.
She said, "I see the president talk of Islam as a religion of peace, I see him host an iftar every year, I see him accept people for who they are and allowing them to have faith in what they choose, or none if they so choose. So I reject this notion of fundamentalism. I have never witnessed it."
Asked why she was a Republican, Powell replied, "I’m just a big believer that people, not government, should be able to make decisions for themselves."
But human rights groups charge that racial profiling and harassment of Muslim- and Arab-Americans are still being practiced by government agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Department of Justice, and the Transportation Safety Administration, the body within the Department of Homeland Security responsible for screening airline passengers and maintaining federal ‘no-fly’ lists.
Despite the high-profile nominations of Karen Hughes and Dina Powell, Washington’s public diplomacy efforts remain problematic, particularly in the Middle East.
Opinions of the U.S. remain at an historic low. And the country’s expensive broadcasting operations, including the Arabic-language satellite TV channel, Al Hurra, have to date failed to attract significant audiences.
Commenting on Powell’s nomination, Shibley Telhami, Anwar Sadat professor for peace and development at the University of Maryland, said, "People are not going to legitimize the policy because someone is speaking Arabic to them."
Criticisms of Washington’s current public diplomacy efforts have come both at home and abroad.
A number of U.S. and overseas commissions and think-tank reports have faulted the Bush administration for not fully explaining U.S. policies and practices. Typical was a report issued late last year by a bipartisan commission appointed by Pres. Bush. It concluded that the U.S. campaign to communicate its ideas and ideals, particularly to Muslim audiences, was "uncoordinated and underfunded, and risks sending contradictory messages about U.S. intentions."
And Dr. John Brown, who resigned from the State Department to protest the invasion of Iraq and who is now a research associate at the Institute for the Study of Diplomacy at Georgetown University in Washington D.C., told IPS, "The objective of public diplomacy should be to win long-term friends for the U.S. One way to do that is to respect others, which the administration seems incapable of."
"The Bush White House doesn’t really believe in diplomacy – if it did, would it select John Bolton as U.S. ambassador to the UN? – so how can it possibly believe in public diplomacy?"
Virtually all commentators agree that student and cultural exchanges are among Washington’s public diplomacy success stories. However, the United States Advisory Commission on Public Diplomacy complained that these exchange programs have been burdened by “redundant" security measures and “excessive" visa fees.
ECA-sponsored exchange programs have served more than 800,000 people from 185 countries, including more than 200 former or current heads of state and 1,500 cabinet ministers.
However, post-9/11, the difficulties of obtaining student visas and Muslim fear of "Islamophobia" in the U.S. have caused a precipitous decline in foreign enrollments in American colleges.
Powell has assured the Senate Foreign Relations Committee she intends to try to remove such obstacles, and her close relationship to the president and to Karen Hughes can only help.
