The Nasser Hospital Attack and Israel’s Relentless Lies

The more atrocious Israel’s actions are, the more desperate their lies become.

by | Nov 16, 2026 | 0 comments

Reprinted with permission from Andy Worthington’s Substack.

As the world was reeling from the State of Israel’s latest atrocity in Gaza — an aerial attack that, without warning, tore through three floors of the surgical wing of Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis just before midnight on November 11, killing six people, including a doctor, and wounding 30 others — the IDF posted a chilling image on X, showing five hospitals in total — Nasser Hospital, the European Hospital, Al-Shifa Hospital, Al-Quds Hospital and Kamal Adwan Hospital — with thumbnail photos allegedly illustrating the presence of weapons “used by Hamas for terror purposes” at all five locations, hinting at further strikes to come on the other four hospitals.

The IDF’s risible “illustration” of weapons at five hospitals in Gaza allegedly “used by Hamas for terror purposes.”

As the world was reeling from the State of Israel’s latest atrocity in Gaza — an aerial attack that, without warning, tore through three floors of the surgical wing of Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis just before midnight on November 11, killing six people, including a doctor, and wounding 30 others — the IDF posted a chilling image on X, showing five hospitals in total — Nasser Hospital, the European Hospital, Al-Shifa Hospital, Al-Quds Hospital and Kamal Adwan Hospital — with thumbnail photos allegedly illustrating the presence of weapons “used by Hamas for terror purposes” at all five locations, hinting at further strikes to come on the other four hospitals.

The IDF claimed in its post that the attack on Nasser Hospital struck “a senior Hamas terrorist and additional terrorists” operating within the hospital, “to eliminate the threat they posed”, alleging that “Hamas used the hospital complex as a hub for military and terrorist activities against IDF troops and Israel”, including “storing weapons, conducting interrogations and torture, operating command-and-control rooms [and] using hospital facilities as observation posts and shelters for terrorists.”

In a follow-up post, the IDF alleged that the Hamas commander who was “struck” was Khan Younis Brigade Commander Muhammad Abu Ismail — and “additional terrorists” — who were “hiding inside” the hospital, adding that Abu Ismail “was responsible for directing terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians & IDF troops and for holding numerous hostages captive throughout the war”, and that “Hamas turned the hospital complex into a headquarters to advance dozens of terrorist attacks and restore the brigade’s terror capabilities.”

The post also claimed that, “Prior to the strike, advance warnings were issued to the civilian population & precision-guided munitions and aerial surveillance assets were employed to minimize the risk of harm to civilians”, both of which seem to be outright lies, firstly because everyone in the hospital was completely unprepared, and, secondly, because the damage caused, and the civilian deaths, are very evidently the opposite of what could legitimately be regarded as “precision-guided.”

Later, the IDF cobbled together a claim that the hospital’s second floor “serves as a Hamas military HQ, where civilians are not permitted to enter, as it is used by Hamas commanders”, including Abu Ismail, and presented a feeble AI-generated film purporting to show this secret headquarters, as well as a map purporting to show three rooms used by three alleged Hamas commanders — Abu Hosna and Muhammad Tarim, about whom no information appears to be publicly available, as well as Abu Ismail.

A screenshot from the IDF’s risible AI-generated video purporting to show the Hamas “military HQ” in Nasser Hospital.

In another follow-up post, the IDF then publicized a 2019 Hamas document, purportedly “found near [a] safe house”, which “outlines a protocol for handling suspects taken for interrogation”, and “identifies Nasser Hospital, the Red Crescent Hospital & the European Hospital as interrogation locations”, also claiming that “a 2020 document, found near Shifa Hospital, details Islamic Jihad’s exploitation of Shifa, Al-Rantisi & Kamal Adwan hospitals to position mortar shells, document rocket launches, take over offices & establish an operations room.”

The IDF then posted thumbnail profiles of eight alleged Hamas “terrorists” who were “eliminated” in Gaza over the last week, two who allegedly “infiltrated Israel during the October 7 Massacre”, and another “involved in manufacturing weapons at [a] dismantled workshop.”

Ramy Abdu, law professor and the chairman of the Geneva-based Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, immediately responded by noting how, “Every week, the Israeli army publishes names of Palestinians it claims to have killed because they were Hamas members or participated in October 7. Yet every time, we identify civilians among them, including people opposed to Hamas with no political involvement.”

“Take Ali Abu Asi, whom I personally knew”, Abdu added, with reference to the IDF’s claim that he was the “terrorist who took part in manufacturing weapons for Hamas.” As Abdu stated, “He was a Fatah supporter, openly opposed to Hamas, and was growing potatoes when Israel killed him. Visit his mourning tent, and you’ll find it organized by Fatah, with Fatah members receiving condolences. This is how Israel falsely labels its victims to justify killing them.”

Just as significantly, none of the names provided by Israel include the alleged target of the attack on Nasser Hospital, Muhammad Abu Ismail, who seems to have evaded death if he — or any of his other spectral “terrorist” companions — were ever there in the first place. He may have been a target, but he was not “struck”, as the IDF claimed.

Instead, all we have are six dead civilians, including a 13-year old patient recovering from surgery, and Dr. Rezq Abu Sheera, 53, a hugely well-respected surgeon, remembered as a “super enthusiastic” individual, who was “always ready to do anything and everything to try to save lives” by the US doctor Feroze Sidhwa, who worked with him at Nasser Hospital, and pointed out that he was featured in the recently-released documentary film “American Doctor”, and that he appeared alongside him in a promotional poster for the film.

Dr. Rezq Abu Sheera, on the left, with Dr. Feroze Sidhwa, in the center, in a promotional poster for the documentary film “American Doctor.”

In an interview with Samira Mohyeddin for On The Line Media, Dr. Blayne Sayed, a visiting Canadian doctor who had just returned from Nasser Hospital last week, explained in detail how all three floors struck in Israel’s attack contained nothing but surgery wards, recovery rooms, surgeons’ offices and sleeping quarters. As he said, discussing how he had been checking in with colleagues, who described “near miss” situations where they too could have been killed, “All of these people are normal professional outstanding people, like I would work with here.”

He couldn’t stress enough how, even after three years of a sickeningly illegal “war” on Gaza’s hospitals, Israel’s poisonous lies about doctors, like journalists, not being doctors at all, but “terrorists” masquerading as doctors, has meant that all of these “normal professional outstanding people” — if they are Palestinian — are persistently regarded with suspicion.

In addition, as Drop Site News reported, two other senior surgeons on duty were badly wounded. One, Dr. Mohammed Aladaini, “lost a leg and is expected to have his other leg amputated as well”, while the other, Dr. Ayman Abu Obaid, is in intensive care, where he spoke about the terror of the attack to Al Arabiya.

It was also revealed that the US government was directly implicated in the attack, which had involved two GBU-39/B bombs, 250-pound bombs developed by Boeing for the US military. One of the bombs, sickeningly displaying its origins, had failed to explode, preventing further casualties, but also devastatingly implicating the US in the unjustifiable civilian slaughter.

The unexploded US-manufactured and US-supplied GBU-39/B bomb that hit Nasser Hospital, and shrapnel from the bomb that did explode, killing six civilians.

As for Israel’s rationale for attacking Nasser Hospital, are we meant not to notice that the past is mixed up with the present in ways that make a mockery of the IDF’s claims? We’re meant to believe that, because it is suggested that hostages were held at Nasser Hospital in the past, and that some ill-defined and unverifiable torture took place, it is somehow morally or militarily acceptable to bomb the hospital over a year since the last hostages were released.

We’re also meant to endorse further attacks on four more hospitals in Gaza because of documents allegedly found by the IDF, and allegedly written by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad in 2019 and 2020, which identified them as locations for military activities, just as we’re also meant to forget that these hospitals have been repeatedly attacked over the last three years.

In the case of Nasser Hospital, this was the seventh attack since October 2023, the last and most notorious example involving the targeted murder of 22 journalists and medical staff in a “double-tap” strike in August 2025, which caused global condemnation, and led to a searingly critical report by Reuters.

In the IDF’s version of reality, it is as if some weird time loop of amnesia is in effect, which justifies attacking Nasser Hospital, the European Hospital, Al-Shifa Hospital, Al-Quds Hospital and Kamal Adwan Hospital over and over and over again, as though, every time they have been attacked, invaded and decommissioned, with often significant losses of life and the abduction of doctors and medical personnel, these facilities have miraculously reconstituted themselves as “terrorist” facilities, where the past permanently bleeds into the present, and all of Gaza’s hospitals are, perpetually, legitimate “terrorist” targets.

All of the above is, of course, not only an insult to our intelligence, but a constant and unforgivable demonstration of Israel’s contempt for all of the long-established and internationally agreed rules regarding the absolute protection given to hospitals, medical staff and patients during military conflicts.

Hospitals only lose their protected status if they are used “to commit, outside their humanitarian functions, an ‘act harmful to the enemy.’” That means specific actions that Israel has repeatedly alleged, but never verified, but it never means the right to drop bombs on medical facilities with no concern for the loss of civilian lives — whether of doctors, other medical staff, or patients.

Israel doesn’t care, however. As we now know — from the documentary film “NAZA”, in particular — and must never forget, the State of Israel believes that up to 20 civilian deaths as “collateral damage” are acceptable when pursuing any military target, with many times more deaths acceptable in pursuit of a high-profile target.

Israel also doesn’t care if the target wasn’t even there, as seems to have been the case in the latest attack on Nasser Hospital, because there is neither contrition nor punishment for Israel killing civilians, even if the alleged target of an attack was never even there in the first place.

Andy Worthington is a freelance investigative journalist, activist, author, photographer (of a photo-journalism project, ‘The State of London’, which ran from 2012 to 2023), film-maker and singer-songwriter (the lead singer and main songwriter for the London-based band The Four Fathers, whose music is available via Bandcamp). He is the co-founder of the Close Guantánamo campaign (see the ongoing photo campaign here) and the successful We Stand With Shaker campaign of 2014-15, and the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison and of two other books: Stonehenge: Celebration and Subversion and The Battle of the Beanfield. He is also the co-director (with Polly Nash) of the documentary film, “Outside the Law: Stories from Guantánamo”, which you can watch on YouTube here.

To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to Andy’s new Substack account, set up in November 2024, where he’ll be sending out a weekly newsletter, or his RSS feed — and he can also be found on Facebook (and here), Twitter and YouTube. Also see the six-part definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, The Complete Guantánamo Files, the definitive Guantánamo habeas list, and the full military commissions list.  Please also consider joining the Close Guantánamo campaign, and, if you appreciate Andy’s work, feel free to make a donation via PayPal or via Stripe.

Andy Worthington is a historian based in London. He is the author of The Guantánamo Files, the first book to tell the stories of all the detainees in Guantanámo. He writes regularly on issues related to Guantánamo and the "War on Terror" on his Web site.

Join the Discussion!

We welcome thoughtful and respectful comments. Hateful language, illegal content, or attacks against Antiwar.com will be removed.

For more details, please see our Comment Policy.