Is Israel Sliding Towards a Police State?
RAMALLAH — Israeli nuclear whistle-blower Mordechai Vanunu has been sentenced to another three months imprisonment for allegedly refusing to perform community service in West Jerusalem.
Vanunu, a former employee at Israel’s secret Dimona nuclear facility in the Negev desert, spent 18 years in jail after he revealed information about the facility to the international media.
He was kidnapped by Israel’s intelligence agency Mossad in Rome and brought back to Israel where he served his sentence, most of it in solitary confinement.
Vanunu was ordered on his release not to speak to foreigners or the international media, an order he has broken numerous times.
However, remarks by the prosecutor that Vanunu still poses a threat to Israel’s security decades after he was sentenced and had already revealed all he knew has raised questions about whether he is being unnecessarily persecuted.
Just how much power Israel’s domestic intelligence agency the Shin Bet has and whether Israel might be turning into a police state has also been the subject of media speculation recently.
This follows the secret midnight arrests of a Turkish national and several Israeli-Arabs on espionage allegations and the gag orders surrounding the arrests.
There are a number of other incidents involving the Shin Bet. At the beginning of the year the Shabak, as the Shin Bet is also known, placed a gag order on the circumstances surrounding the arrest and interrogation of Israeli journalist Anat Kam.
Kam is alleged to have copied secret Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) documentation on extra-judicial killings of Palestinian resistance fighters with the liquidations being carried out in contravention of Israeli court rulings.
Israelis were the last to find out about Kam’s house arrest, months after it happened, when it made big news internationally and was reported extensively on the Internet.
A week ago two Israeli Arabs, Ameer Makhoul from Haifa, the director general of the Ittijah charity, and Omar Said, a member of the Balad political party, were arrested by the Shin Bet and heavily armed anti-terror squads during night raids on their family apartments.
The two have been accused of passing on information to the Lebanese resistance organization’s, Hezbollah. The Shin Bet again placed a gag on the arrests until a few days ago with some of the details still remaining secret.
Critics argue that the allegations are flimsy at best and have more to do with Makhoul supporting a boycott of Israeli settlement goods and his campaigning for equal rights for Israeli-Arabs.
Speculation is also rife that Makhoul’s brother Amir’s (a former member of the Israeli Knesset) speech to the Knesset, about Israel’s clandestine nuclear armaments and his comments that Israel should begin nuclear disarmament, had already focused security attention on the family.
Makhoul’s arrest comes at a time when the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) is slated to discuss Israel’s nuclear program for the very first time ever at its forthcoming June meeting.
A number of other Palestinian grassroots activists, involved in the Boycott, Disinvestment Sanctions (BDS) campaign and protests against Israel’s separation barrier, remain incarcerated in Israeli jails in administrative detention or without trial. Abdullah Abu Rahme, a member of Bili’in’s village committee against Israel’s separation barrier, which has expropriated large swathes of the village’s land, has been held for more than five months in administrative detention.
The Israeli authorities accuse him of incitement in planning weekly non-violent demonstrations, supported by Israeli and international activists, against the wall as well as possession of arms.
The latter accusation relates to his arrangement of used teargas canisters and rubber-coated metal bullets into a peace sign after the IDF had fired them at protestors.
Another Shin Bet gag order was placed several weeks ago on the arrest in the West Bank of Turkish national Izzet Shahin, a volunteer for the Turkish NGO Foundation for Human Rights and Freedoms and Humanitarian Relief (IHH).
Izzet is accused of belonging to IHH, an Islamic group outlawed by Israel, and of helping to organize an aid boat to Gaza as part of the flotilla of humanitarian relief which is heading towards the coastal territory at the end of May.
The deportation several weeks ago of a famous Spanish clown from Israel’s Ben Gurion international airport on the grounds he intended to make contact with "terror organizations" while in Ramallah has seen some Israeli commentators calling the Shin Bet "the real clowns."
Ivan Prado had planned to take part in an international clown festival in Ramallah but after six hours of interrogation by the Shin Bet he was refused entry to Israel and deported to Spain on "security grounds."
The incident caused embarrassment at the Israeli Foreign Ministry and heightened tensions with the Spanish government.
Meanwhile, a number of Israeli leftists are facing trial for "rioting and assaulting police" during a non-violent protest in the East Jerusalem suburb of Sheikh Jarrah. They were protesting Israel’s building of illegal Jewish settlements and Judaization of the neighborhood at the expense of the Palestinian locals.
The protestors claim the charges are trumped up and they were arrested after they refused to disperse during a demonstration approved by an Israeli court.
In another development, IDF military intelligence has also caught flak for over-ruling an Israeli court decision to fully open a main highway in the West Bank to Palestinian motorists.
Highway 443 has been used by Jewish settlers exclusively for years even though it is built on Palestinian land and it runs alongside many Palestinian villages.
Despite the court ruling the IDF will only open parts of the highway to Palestinian motorists and only after extensive security checks at roadblocks at the highway’s entrance.
In further breaking news several Palestinian medical students have been refused entry permits to Jerusalem to continue their studies at Jerusalem’s Al Quds University after they refused to spy for the Shin Bet on student activity there.
The Shin Bet declined to discuss the issue other than to say the permits had been denied "on security grounds."
(Inter Press Service)
Read more by Mel Frykberg
- Palestinian Prisoners Languish in Administrative Detention – August 10th, 2011
- Palestinians Prepare for Massive Uprising – July 29th, 2011
- ‘Flytilla’ Debacle Another PR Nightmare For Israel – July 11th, 2011
- A Zionist Fights for Palestinian Rights – June 28th, 2011
- Palestinian Children Targeted as Israel Crushes Unrest – June 16th, 2011





epppie
May 13th, 2010 at 9:46 am
People in a police state never know it is one. But they know to be careful what they say and to whom they say it. And if they are honest about it, they know to be thankful that they aren't in one of the specially targeted populations. But they don't live in a police state.
Guests
May 13th, 2010 at 4:20 pm
Definition of a Police State is when the social laws of a country is based on control and more control of its people, when there is no freedom for minority, when there is a concept in fear and miss trust, when there is a concept in religious supremacy or for that matter a social supremacy based on color, religion, and other social values, but above all a social political climates where a number of people are demonized and classified as not worthy yet used and abused for when and how these people make a profit for the very same politicians or its economical infrastructure. Here.., the question shouldn’t be focused just about Israel but rather where Israel is getting its economical power to establish itself as a Police state.
In another word and in principals.., if democracy in terms of its economical and political ethics in industrialized countries ever existed then such apartheid regime as Israel wouldn’t be allowed to steal the Arabs land and call itself a only democracy in Middle East.
Guests
May 14th, 2010 at 12:09 am
2- if Israel wasn’t a militarism regime then it wouldn’t be a apartheid nor a police state, so the relativity in asking if Israel is “gliding toward a police state” is irrelevant, in another word Israel is already a police state combined and connected with all the above. Yes there is a keenest – parliament and people vote but that doesn’t mean that the social political and economic principals is based on democracy and the ethics of democracy is practiced by the politicians or Israel theocrats fanatics who runs the government of Israel…, the last war crime committed by the Israelis army in Gaza is yet another proof of the argument.
Andrewp111
May 14th, 2010 at 2:12 am
Israel has always been a police state. Back in the 1980s when I was in college, US travelers to Israel related their experiences as such. A state in perpetual war must, almost by definition, be a police state. There is nothing new to see here. Move along.
Andrewp111
May 13th, 2010 at 7:12 pm
Israel has always been a police state. Back in the 1980s when I was in college, US travelers to Israel related their experiences as such. A state in perpetual war must, almost by definition, be a police state. The longstanding corruption of Israeli officials is also legendary, and endemic corruption goes hand in hand with authoritarian regimes. There is nothing new to see here. Move along.
kapoore
May 13th, 2010 at 8:16 pm
If Israelis haven't noticed their country sliding into a police state, the same could be said for American Jews who are still completely swept away with awe at the mere mention of Israel. There is no place in the public arena where there is quite as much cognitive dissonance as between the 'alternative presses' view of Israel and that of the American Jews. Recently I spent an evening with a person who had just come back from celebrating Israel's 60th birthday and he was gushing with admiration for Israeli society. Then I come home to the internet and read what is going on there, and I am stunned by the cultural bubble most American Jews live in….It's as if they have filtered out everything negative that has ever been written about Israel, or maybe they believe it is all a pack of lies spread by anti-semites. Totally amazing!!
sideboom
May 20th, 2010 at 2:53 am
I was in israel for 18 months,,, of course its a police state of the worst kind, they got a nazi back from south america and murdered him , they used 82 agents of massaad to murder Jerrold Bull in belgium ,he was building a super cannon in irag that could fire satelites into space, jews world wide have the best spy network , but this same network is dedicated to zionism and the stolen land ,
sideboom
May 20th, 2010 at 2:54 am
should i refrain from further comment mr. adminestrator ?