Do the Republicans Ever Learn?
In August 2008, as the world’s leaders gathered in Beijing for the Olympic games, Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili, hot-headed and erratic, made his gamble for greatness.
It began with a stunning artillery barrage on Tskhinvali, capital of tiny South Ossetia, a province that had broken free of Tbilisi when Tbilisi broke free of Russia. As Ossetians and Russian peacekeepers fell under the Georgian guns, terrified Ossetians fled into Russia.
Saakashvili’s blitzkrieg appeared to have triumphed.
Until, that is, Russian armor, on Vladimir Putin’s orders, came thundering down the Roki Tunnel into Ossetia, sending Saakashvili’s army reeling. The Georgians were driven out of Ossetia and expelled from a second province that had broken free of Tbilisi: Abkhazia.
The Russians then proceeded to bomb Tbilisi, capture Gori, birthplace of Joseph Stalin, and bomb Georgian airfields rumored to be the forward bases for the Israelis in any pre-emptive strike on Iran.
The humiliation of Saakashvili was total, and brought an enraged and frustrated John McCain running to the microphones.
"Today, we’re all Georgians," bawled McCain.
Well, not exactly.
President Bush called Putin’s response "disproportionate" and "brutal," but did nothing. Small nations that sucker-punch big powers do not get to dictate when the fisticuffs stop.
What made this war of interest to Americans, however, was that Bush had long sought to bring Georgia into NATO. Only the resistance of Old Europe had prevented it.
And had Georgia been a member of NATO when Saakashvili began his war, U.S. Marines and Special Forces might have been on the way to the Caucasus to confront Russian troops in a part of the world where there is no vital U.S. interest and never has been any U.S. strategic interest whatsoever.
A U.S war with Russia – over Georgia, Abkhazia and South Ossetia – would have been an act of national criminal insanity.
Days later, there came another startling discovery.
McCain foreign policy adviser Randy Scheunemann had been paid $290,000 by the Saakashvili regime, from January 2007 to March 2008, to get Georgia into NATO, and thus acquire a priceless U.S. war guarantee to fight on Georgia’s side in any clash with Russia.
What makes this history relevant today?
Last week, Sen. Marco Rubio, rising star of the Republican right, on everyone’s short list for VP, called for a unanimous vote, without debate, on a resolution directing President Obama to accept Georgia’s plan for membership in NATO at the upcoming NATO summit in Chicago.
Rubio was pushing to have the U.S. Senate pressure Obama into fast-tracking Georgia into NATO, making Tbilisi an ally the United States would be obligated by treaty to go to war to defend.
Now it is impossible to believe a senator, not a year in office, dreamed this up himself. Some foreign agent of Scheunemann’s ilk had to have had a role in drafting it.
And for whose benefit is Rubio pushing to have his own countrymen committed to fight for a Georgia that, three years ago, started an unprovoked war with Russia? Who cooked up this scheme to involve Americans in future wars in the Caucasus that are none of our business?
The answer is unknown. What is known is the name of the senator who blocked it – Rand Paul, son of Ron Paul, who alone stepped in and objected, defeating Rubio’s effort to get a unanimous vote.
The resolution was pulled. But these people will be back. They are indefatigable when it comes to finding ways to commit the blood of U.S. soldiers to their client regimes and ideological bedfellows.
Back in 2008, however, as Bush was confining himself to protesting the excesses of Russia’s response, his ex-U.N. ambassador was full of righteous rage and ready for military action.
In the London Telegraph, Aug. 15, 2008, John Bolton declared that Russia had conducted an "invasion," that Georgia had been a "victim of aggression," that America had "fiddled while Georgia burned," that we had played the "paper tiger"when faced by the snarling Russian Bear.
As for the European Union, in bringing about a ceasefire, it had achieved results "approaching Neville Chamberlain’s moment in the spotlight at Munich."
But did not Georgia launch the attack that started the war?
"This confrontation is not about who violated the Marquis of Queensbury’s rule in South Ossetia," scoffed Bolton. Russia planned this "rape" because brave little Georgia refused to be "Finlandized."
Restoring America’s credibility, said Bolton, now requires "drawing a clear line for Russia" in the Caucasus and elsewhere.
And who is John Bolton?
Newt Gingrich told two groups Wednesday he intends to name Bolton secretary of state.
With Newt appointing as America’s first diplomat an uber-hawk who makes Dick Cheney look like Gandhi, and Mitt Romney’s foreign policy team crawling with neocons primed for war with Iran, a vote for the GOP in 2012 looks more and more like a vote for war.
Like the Bourbons of old, the Republican Party seems to have learned nothing and forgotten nothing.
Read more by Patrick J. Buchanan
- What Should Americans Die For? – May 16th, 2013
- Who Are the War Criminals in Syria? – May 6th, 2013
- Their War, Not Ours – April 29th, 2013
- Is War With North Korea Inevitable? – April 4th, 2013
- Goading Gullible America Into War – March 21st, 2013





Drake
December 10th, 2011 at 7:28 am
Chicken hawks, Gingrich and Romney, were draft age during Viet Nam. Both evaded the draft by using various deferrments. Neither served. Romney has five sons: none of them have served in the military.
Bianca
December 10th, 2011 at 7:38 am
Wars of any kind mean money, money, money, money. Which we do not have, but who cares. We will print, print, print, print. Buchanan is right. We are the Bourbons of old.
Steve
December 10th, 2011 at 9:07 am
I hope this isn't too far off the main subject of Buchanan's article, but the comment by Bianca about money, money, money – made me think about the treasonous passage of S.1867 with its 'indefinite detention' provisions that would bring our Founding Father's greatest nightmare to reality – the tyrants who have ascended to power in the USA turning the US military loose on the American citizens.
We've all heard about the FEMA detention camps that are supposedly built and if one believes even half of the baloney that Alex Jones puts out – the criminals who've hijacked our government are now staffing these camps up and getting ready to start rounding up dissidents and anyone who is opposed to endless wars for Israel. So, back to Bianca's observation about money.
We are told on a daily basis that the thieves who infest D.C. have been so irresponsible and crooked that they've blown the Social Security 'trust fund' and both SSA and Medicare are in dire financial straights. They lie about our deficit – claiming its about $13 or $14 trillion, when most experts say the real figure is somewhere between $77 and $100 trillion dollars. So, here is my question:
If these treasonous rats in D.C. do order the US military to round up millions of dissidents and throw them into these FEMA camps – where is this government going to get the money to fund those camps? Food, electricity, water, medical needs, plus salaries for the goons and jackboots to herd over the inmates. Who pays for that? They say they can't afford to make good on the mandatory, contributory entitlements – that millions of Americans have been required to pay into, so where will the money come from to pay for the maintenance and up-keep costs for all these FEMA indefinite detention camps?
Judging by how the Bolsheviks ran their slave labor camps, I would assume that the inmates in the FEMA camps would be required to work – and perhaps be forced to pay for their own food and other needs, by some farcical system that would be cooked up. But, bottom line – prisons are expensive things to maintain, and we've all seen various statistics on the cost per-prisoner and the last figures I saw were somewhere around $35k per year, and that figure is a decade or so old.
So, where will the money come from?
andy
December 10th, 2011 at 10:01 am
They get saps to do their dirty work, while living lives of luxury.
andy
December 10th, 2011 at 10:01 am
Note that the Bourbons are no longer around…
Sam
December 10th, 2011 at 10:49 am
John Bolton too avoided the draft and Vietnam.Chicken hawks indeed.
Don
December 10th, 2011 at 1:56 pm
If Ron Paul is not on the ballot, I plan not to vote.
Nelson_2008
December 10th, 2011 at 5:45 pm
I cringe whenever anyone uses the word "learn" in any context involving "politicians" and their handlers.
You might as well ask, why can't serial killers and pedophiles "learn" from their mistakes?
What we've got here is the unfortunate situation where our whole political process has been subverted by madmen. We've got bloodthirsty criminally insane puppet masters pulling the strings of amoral, sociopathic, empty vessels, whose only concern is their own pathological vanity.
Where in this breathtakingly perverse scheme of things does anyone see any opening for any kind of "learning" process?
JoaoAlfaiate
December 11th, 2011 at 5:05 am
Agree!
the lion
December 11th, 2011 at 6:41 am
A forgotten fact here is that the Russians were and still are the OFFICIAL UN security council peacekeepers of the Georgian -Ossetian border region, and also that the Georgians attacked Russian Troops in NORTH OSSETIA as well.
If one looks at the Russian response the Russians took enough Territory to stop Artillery and Rocket attacks and to prevent flanking manouevers by Georgian Forces. The reality they were in fact quite measured minimal responses and were in accordance with UN rules of engagement.for peacekeeping forces.
carroll price
December 11th, 2011 at 7:30 am
I also agree. If Ron Paul is not on the ballot in my state and district, I will proudly stay home. I never again, by default, cast a vote for evil by voting for the lessor of two evils.
curmudgeonvt
December 11th, 2011 at 8:01 am
Bingo!!!
RickR30
December 11th, 2011 at 9:35 am
Good to know that about Rubio. Clearly the man is someone else's puppet. And those who really have the power in America love nothing more than puppets in the White House, and Congress, and the Supreme Court, and as governors. Thanks Marco for unveiling yourself as a whore of the neocons. May this be your only term in Congress.
And here I thought that electing that clinton witch as sec of state was about as big a slap in the face as you could give to the world. In comes Newt and his big empty head. Bolton? Looks like Giraldi's cabinet from hell is going to come true with candidate Newt. Vote for death, vote for Newt-Rubio.
jeff_davis
December 11th, 2011 at 2:42 pm
And white trash Republicans dream of rising to that level of privilege.
jeff_davis
December 11th, 2011 at 2:59 pm
You might consider voting for the GREATER of two evils. After all, America can't rise from the ashes until it first burns down.
R Hoopadoozitz
July 24th, 2012 at 9:13 am
Johnny Bolton is Moroni's foreign policy advisor: South Osse'tia, here we come!