Iran Polls Better Than US in Saudi Arabia

Although the image of the United States appears to have improved in Saudi Arabia over the past year, the Saudi public’s view of Washington remains largely negative, according to major new poll released here this week by Terror Free Tomorrow (TFT), a Washington, D.C.-based bipartisan group.

Indeed, less than 40 percent of some 1,000 Saudi respondents interviewed by telephone during the first week of December, said they have either a "very" or "somewhat favorable" opinion of the US, while nearly 52 percent said their view was either very or somewhat unfavorable, according to the survey results.

By contrast, Iran – which Saudi leaders reportedly consider a dangerous rival for influence in the oil-rich Gulf region – is seen more positively by the Saudi public in general, the poll found.

A plurality of 47 percent said they regarded Tehran either very or somewhat favorably, compared to 44 percent who expressed unfavorable views.

Strong majorities of Saudi respondents, on the other hand, said they held favorable views of Turkey (71 percent) – whose secular traditions would appear to be at odds with Saudi Arabia’s staunchly Islamist orientation – and China (61 percent). Somewhat weaker majorities said they had positive views of France and Britain.

The TFT survey, the latest in a series by the organization of key countries in the Islamic world – including Iran and Pakistan – suggests that Saudi public opinion, especially toward the outside world, is considerably more complex than depicted by the western mass media which has portrayed it as a stronghold of "Wahabi" fanaticism.

Fewer than one in ten Saudis said they had a favorable opinion of al-Qaeda. Eighty-eight percent said they approved of their government’s crackdown against the group and 15 percent said they had a positive impression of the group’s chief and fellow-Saudi, Osama bin Laden.

But strong majorities of those who expressed a favorable opinion of bin Laden and al-Qaeda also said they favored closer ties between the US and Saudi Arabia and insisted that their views of the US would change for the better if Washington changed a number of its policies in the region.

More than two thirds (69 percent) of respondents said they favored better relations with the US

Asked what policy changes would improve their opinion of the US, 85 percent cited the withdrawal of US military forces from Iraq. Seventy-four percent cited increasing student and work visas for Saudis in the US and 71 percent suggested striking a free trade deal between the two countries.

Fifty-two percent of respondents said their view of Washington would improve if it brokered a comprehensive peace between Israel and the Palestinians, while only 36 percent cited Washington’s efforts at promoting democracy in the Middle East.

Nearly two thirds (63 percent) said their view would improve if Washington provided more military assistance to Saudi Arabia, although only 49 percent said they favored the pending sale of billions of dollars in advanced US weaponry to the kingdom, while 32 percent said they opposed it.

While 52 percent of Saudi respondents said they retained a negative opinion of the US, that marked a considerable improvement over the results of a smaller TFT poll taken in May 2006 when 89 percent of Saudi respondents said they held an unfavorable view.

Still, TFT’s director, Ken Ballen, said the 40 percent favorable view suggested that the Saudi public was one of the most pro-US countries in the region. He noted that only around 20 percent of respondents in surveys taken over the past year in Pakistan and Egypt said they had favorable views, while only nine percent of Turks shared that opinion in a May 2007 poll sponsored by the Pew Global Attitudes Project.

"From our surveys and others," he wrote in a summary analysis of the Saudi poll, "there are only two major Muslim majority countries with a higher favorable opinion of the United States: Bangladesh and Iran."

As heartening as that conclusion appeared to be, the US and Americans ranked were still seen least favorably among seven nations and their citizens on whom respondents were asked to give their opinions.

Only four in ten Saudis said they felt positively about Americans. Favorable opinions of the British were voiced by 48 percent of respondents. Fifty-two percent said they had favorable views of Iranians, while the French, at 57 percent, were viewed somewhat more favorably Nearly three out of four respondents said they had a positive view of Turks.

"It’s not like they’re locked into an anti-western framework," noted Steve Kull, director of the University of Maryland’s Program on International Policy Attitudes (PIPA), citing the statistics for Britain and France.

Kull, whose organization has done extensive polling in the Middle East, also noted that the relatively favorable views towards Iran suggested that the Saudi public does not share the same fears about Tehran as the royal family.

Nearly one third of Saudi respondents said they had a favorable opinion of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad – nearly three times the percentage of those who had positive views of Bush.

Still, 57 percent of respondents said they opposed the development by Iran of nuclear weapons. Thirty-eight percent said they would favor the US and other countries taking military action to prevent the Iranians from obtaining such a weapon, compared to 27 percent who said the US should accept a nuclear-armed Iran.

Saudis were particularly sympathetic toward Iraqis for whom more than four in five respondents expressed favorable views. Iraq also appeared to be the dominant source of unhappiness with the US.

Despite their strong antipathy toward al-Qaeda, 36 percent of respondents said they supported Saudi citizens going to Iraq to fight US forces there. Only 17 percent said they supported Saudis fighting Shi’ite militias in Iraq.

Saudi respondents expressed an almost uniform antipathy toward Jews. Only six percent said they held favorable views of Jews. Nearly nine of ten said their views were unfavorable (81 percent "very unfavorable").

A slight majority of 51 percent said they would oppose any peace treaty recognizing Israel, while 30 percent said they would favor such a treaty on the condition that Palestinians establish a state of their own.

Attitudes towards Christians were more divided. Forty-four percent expressed favorable views, while 54 percent said they had unfavorable opinions (40 percent "very unfavorable").

(Inter Press Service)

Read more by Jim Lobe

Author: Jim Lobe

Jim Lobe writes for Inter Press Service.